According to People, the couple of three years tied the knot in front of 50 family and friends on a private estate in Kihei on the island of Maui.
The bride and groom, as seen in People's exclusive wedding photo, looked amazing on their big day. Morrison, who plays Mr. Schue on the hit FOX show, wore a custom Brooks Brothers tuxedo for the destination wedding, while his brand-new wife donned a long-sleeved Gustavo Cadile wedding dress paired with a flower crown.
See more: Our Favorite Celebrity Engagement Rings
The wedding included musical performances from pianist Chad Whidden and soloist Kiley Dean, who sang "Feels Like Home" as Puente walked down the aisle.
The fun didn't stop there. People reports that Puente performed a Hula dance for her new husband during the reception, which he then joined! They also sang a duet of Laura Benanti's "Starry Eyed/Video Games" for their guests.
"It was a small affair," a source told Us Weekly of the joyous occasion. "They wanted to keep it intimate and special."
Their musical wedding matches their over-the-top engagement announcement last year. Elton John and David Furnish announced Morrison and Puente's betrothal in June 2013 at their White Tie and Tiara Ball in London, which the couple attended as friends of the hosts. Coldplay's Chris Martin joined John to serenade the couple with a duet of "Your Song."