Every Wedding Cake Question You've Ever Had, Answered

Choosing a wedding cake is not exactly a cake walk

Updated 09/26/17

Photo by Phillip Van Nostrand

Everyone loves wedding cake, but choosing what to serve is no cake walk!

From picking flavors and designs to alternative desserts and when to serve them, we’ve rounded up some of the top wedding cake questions to help you choose the perfect sweet ending for your wedding day.

01 of 07

"I love chocolate, but my partner prefers fruitier flavors. Do we have to pick one?"

Wedding Cake with Dark Tones and Roses

Photo by Kelly Anne Berry

Why limit yourself to one cake flavor when you can have two—or more? Bakers today are frequently crafting tiers that feature different cake and filling combinations to satisfy both halves of the couple, as well as their guests. So if you’d rather have a dark chocolate cake with peanut butter filling, while your partner is all about that salted caramel or seasonal peach preserves, have both! Talk to your baker about strategizing which tiers feature each flavor to get a more even divide, and consider a slightly larger cake—your guests will want to try both offerings!

02 of 07

"When should we cut our cake?"

Nearly-Naked Chocolate Cake with Gold Foil

Photo by Chaz Cruz; Cake by Lucky Bird Bakery

While it might seem arbitrary, the timing of your cake cutting actually plays a big role in your reception. In the past, the cake cutting was the very last moment in the reception—signaling to guests that they were welcome to head home. Though it usually happens much earlier today, cutting your cake still serves that same purpose (especially for older guests). These days, the cake is usually cut toward the end of dinner, just before dancing begins, and is the last "official" event of the evening. Slicing on the earlier side will let your grandmother or great uncle know they’re welcome to depart whenever they’re ready, and will signal that they won’t miss any of the formalities if they choose to head home.

There are a few other bonuses to cut the cake early (even before you take your seats for dinner!). First, it ensures your photographer gets those pictures. If you’ve scheduled your photographer to leave around 9pm, cutting the cake at 7pm means they won’t miss it. It also makes slicing and serving easier for your catering staff. If you cut the cake before dinner, they can work on slicing it once entrées have been served, and can pass out pieces as a plated dessert course before dancing gets underway.

03 of 07

"What’s the best way to cut a wedding cake?"

Wedding Cake with Dog Topper

Photo by Rachel Buckley Weddings

Have you and your partner practiced cutting a cake together before? Probably not, and we don’t blame you! Having two sets of hands on that cake knife can definitely be tricky. The neatest methods are either the box or wedge options. With the bride closest to the cake and the groom behind her, place both of your hands onto the knife. Cut an inch into the cake and slice down cleanly. Then, make a connecting cut for a wedge, using the cake knife to lift the wedge out and onto the plate. Skip the serving spatula, which is much larger than the slice should be and will just make a mess. For an even neater option, go with the box method: After you make that first slice, make a second parallel cut an inch over. Then, insert the knife vertically at the back of your two cuts and use it to push the slice out onto the plate.

04 of 07

"I want to surprise my new husband with a groom’s cake. What should it look like? When is it served?"

Croquembouche Wedding Cake

Photo by Harwell Photography

Traditionally, groom’s cakes were the wedding favor, not another dessert. The cake was sliced, boxed, and given to guests to take home. Single women would then sleep with the cake under their pillow, hoping to dream of their future groom—hence the cake’s name. These days, a groom’s cake is a chance to add something special for the groom to a celebration that can often feel like it’s all about the bride. Displayed alongside the wedding cake, a groom’s cake can take any form and be any flavor, whether a traditionally-shaped cake in rich chocolate with a liqueur filling or the funfetti of his childhood, carved into the shape of his prized grill or emblazoned with his favorite team’s logo.

Since the cake used to be used as a favor instead of dessert, there aren’t any hard-and-fast rules about slicing and serving. Most couples opt to slice the groom’s cake immediately after cutting the wedding cake, and serving slices alongside pieces of the wedding cake so guests have a choice of flavors. If the cakes are both large enough, you could plate a duet of slices for each guest, or simply put one flavor on each plate and let your family and friends choose what they’d prefer.

05 of 07

"Do we need to offer additional desserts, or can we serve only cake?"

Nearly-Naked Drip Wedding Cake with Red Glaze

Photo by Emily Kirke Photography; Cake by Erica O'Brien

It’s sweet and served after dinner, so wedding cake sounds like dessert to us! As a wedding tradition (and a favorite celebratory dessert year-round), a slice of cake is a perfect way to end the meal.

Of course, there’s nothing stopping you from adding a little variety! For some extra sweetness, have your caterers set trays of truffles and chocolate-covered strawberries on each table as a sweet bite that’s not quite as filling as a big slice of cake. Or opt for a composed cake plate, with a scoop of ice cream or a drizzle of sauce to enhance that slice. You could also use additional desserts as a late night snack, setting out milk and cookies or arranging for an ice cream sundae bar to give guests extra energy for that late night dance party.

06 of 07

"Can we save the leftover tiers of our wedding cake?"

Two-Tiered Wedding Cake with Roses

Photo by Amber Vickery

It’s a long-standing tradition for the bride and groom to save the top tier of their wedding cake to share on their first anniversary. Just make sure you tell your baker and caterer in advance! This way your baker can provide a box to fit the top tier, and your caterer won’t accidentally serve it. The next day, wrap the cake tightly in multiple layers of plastic wrap, then tuck it in the box and wrap the whole thing in more plastic wrap to fend of freezer burn.

If there is more cake leftover, offer slices for your guests to take home as an extra treat. If it hasn’t yet been sliced, wrap it up and bring it to brunch the next day as a surprise dessert for those guests who are still in town.

07 of 07

"Do we have to have a wedding cake?"

Couple Kissing Over Wedding Cake

Photo by Katelyn James Photography

We’ve yet to have a run-in with the wedding cake police, so we say do whatever sounds good to you! If you and your partner prefer fruit pies, doughnuts, or cookies instead of cake, those all make great wedding dessert options. Arrange them on cake stands or pretty trays, and don’t forget to share one with your new spouse as the first sweet bite of your marriage!

Not into sweets? Don’t skip dessert entirely, as your guests will be expecting it as a conclusion to the meal. Instead, talk to your caterer about a plated option that can be served after the entrées, or arrange a dessert bar where guests can choose whatever tempts their sweet tooth, and skip that cake cutting photo altogether. If coffee or a nightcap are more your speed, pair the sweets with your favorite way to end the night for a personalized touch.

Related Stories