We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.
If a round, princess, oval, pear, cushion, or emerald-cut diamond does not appeal to you, chances are you’re an unconventional bride. With a taste level that often defies tradition, you’re drawn to engagement rings with a distinctive look such as cuts and settings that appear one-of-a-kind whether it’s a solitaire, cluster, or three-stone ring. But, you're not the only one! Several brides in the spotlight have been gravitating towards unexpected pieces as well. From Lily Collins and
Besides, there are plenty of brides who crave the classics, so choosing a rare engagement ring with a shield-cut diamond, geometric stone, or cluster of uniquely shaped gems will help you stand out in a sea of sparkle. Even brides in the spotlight have been gravitating towards these unexpected pieces. Lily Collins and Heidi Klum sport colored stones, Katy Perry shows off her personal style with a floral-inspired ring, while stars like Ariana Grande and Emily Ratajkowski wear asymmetrical two-stone bling.
Meet the Expert
- Lorraine Brantner is a sales manager for James Allen, a fine jewelry company dedicated to premium customer service and affordable prices.
While a uniquely shaped engagement ring is all about an extreme wow factor, it’s not to say that every design necessitates a stone upwards of three carats. Sure, that would be #goals, but a range of sizes from half-carat diamonds and gemstones to one or two carats can be absolutely striking in a distinctive cut. Shield and portrait cuts—which are an angular alternative to pear and oval-shaped diamonds—are flatter but appear longer on the finger, giving the illusion of a bigger stone, especially with side baguettes or a pavé halo wrapping around. Unexpected shapes like a trapezoid, half-moon, or teardrop are especially exceptional and versatile—depending on your budget, you can opt for a bigger solitaire stone in one of these uncommon cuts, a two-stone ring with contrasting shapes (or stones!), or a cluster ring or band featuring a mix of smaller stones. Rest assured, even the smallest of stones are impactful whether you go for a diamond, gemstone, or a mix of both. Even antique rings like art deco and Edwardian styles come with uniquely shaped stones which is a perfect solution for the vintage bride craving something entirely unique.
Wherever you fall on the unconventional engagement ring spectrum, we culled 30 spectacular styles to inspire you from exceptional cuts to avant-garde shapes. For the bride eschewing tradition, these rings are perfect, no matter your budget.
Bario Neal Lash Cluster Dyad Ring
This dainty yet striking champagne ring features more than one unexpected detail. The mismatching shaped cluster in addition to the two colored stones exude an irresistible visual interest and charm.
Jacquie Aiche Mini Baguette V Band
This piece may just be the definition of vintage beauty. A 14k rose gold band frames an exquisite halo of baguette-shaped diamonds surrounding a diamond-shaped center stone.
Selin Kent Luna Ring
We love how this stone appears as if its floating over this 14k yellow gold band. For the bride seeking an effortlessly magical piece, this half moon shaped diamond may be the perfect fit.
MinimalVS Unique engagement Ring Set, Geometric Moss Agate Ring with Gold V Band, 18k Gold Gemstone Ring Set, Moss Agate Ring Set, Organic Gemstone
There's something so mysterious about this 18k gold elongated diamond-shaped ring. Featuring a cluster of diamonds on either side of the center stone, this deep green moss-inspired ring is like nothing we've ever seen before.
Nora Kogan Pillar Ring
Seriously, how chic is this?! A tapered diamond baguette is set horizontally on a solid gold band. This is such a daringly unique approach to a sophisticated and simple engagement ring.
Apres Jewelry The Beatrix Ring Shield Cut
A double pavè band complements en elongated diamond-shaped stone. To top it all off, an eye-catching halo seamlessly frames the center stone of this completely customizable piece.
Loriann Stevenson Gray Kite Diamond Slice Ring
It's not everyday we see a salt and pepper diamond, but when we do, we can't get enough of it. To make this extraordinary piece even more unique, the stone is cut in one of the most dramatic diamond-cut shapes we've ever seen.
threelayers Hexagon Moss Agate & Moissanite or Diamond Ring, Unique Geometric Engagement Ring, Alternative Mossy Agate Wedding Ring
This is another deep green nature-inspired piece that we're absolutely obsessed with. Intricate and charming, there's so much detail to appreciate within this hexagon-shaped stone.
Shahla Karimi Landmark Series Brooklyn Bridge Ring No.2
This is such a fresh take on a solitaire featuring a pavé diamond band. With inspiration drawn from the bold architecture of New York City, this piece is utterly daring and distinct.
Mark Broumand 2.69ct Fancy Vivid Yellow Trapezoid Cut Diamond Engagement Ring
Talk about a statement piece. A jaw-droppingly irregular diamond halo frames the bright center stone. This striking yellow trapezoid-cut diamond ring will undoubtedly become a piece that will spark conversation for years to come.
Monique Péan MNRACD526P Two Antique Step Cut Trapezoidal White Diamond Ring
Two antique trapezoidal baguette diamonds join together to create an elongated hexagonal affect. Encompassed by a halo of white pavé diamonds, a double band, and a split shank, there's so much detail to fall head over heels in love with.
Tomasz Donocik Stellar Engagement Ring
An 18k rose gold engagement ring features a delicate tension setting creating the illusion of a floating center stone. The baguette-cut white diamonds are just the cherries on top of this once-in-a-lifetime piece.
Van Cleef & Arpels Two Butterfly Between the Finger Ring
So playful and light, this rose gold butterfly design featuring round and marquise-shaped diamonds is simply genius. We love how the two butterflies appear as if they're lightly resting upon the fingers.
Nikos Koulis Yesterday Collection White Gold Ring with White Diamond Baguettes and Rubellite
The asymmetry of this rubellite stunner is utter perfection. A white gold band features white diamond baguettes and a rich center stone in the most captivating way.
Eli Halili Trapezoid Diamond Ring
A trapezoid-shaped stone is a great choice if you're seeking a ring like no other. Set in 18k gold, this 0.84 carat diamond ring is simply polished and chic.
RubyStaUSA Salt and Pepper diamond Ring| Salt and pepper Ring| Pear Diamond Ring | Salt and Pepper Engagement Ring| Wedding Ring| 14k Solid Gold Ring
We love how this asymmetrical halo design adds an unexpected surprise to this pear-shaped salt and pepper diamond. Slightly mysterious yet still elegant, the 14k rose gold band is a stunner.
Angara Round Morganite Cocktail Ring with Floral Diamond Halo
A floral-inspired engagement ring is one of the few designs that is timeless but still wildly unexpected. This customizable piece features 14k white gold and a soft pink morganite center stone.
Mejuri Diamonds Cluster Ring
We just can't resist a good cluster ring. This beauty adds a classic touch to a unique shape and miscellaneous placement of the brilliant white diamonds.
1stDibs Van Cleef & Arpels 4 Leaf Clover Genuine Ruby Diamond Yellow Gold Ring
This chunky and bold four leave clover-inspired ring features a deep red ruby at the center of it all. We're crushing hard over the thick yellow gold band and round diamonds scattered throughout the leaves surrounding the center stone.
Angara Oval Blue Sapphire and Diamond Wedding Band Ring Set
It's all about the setting with this one. While the deep blue sapphire in the oval cut is a tried and true classic style, the unexpected placement of the stones on this intricate yellow gold band is everything.
1stDibs Late Victorian 18kt 2.50 Total Carat Rose Cut Diamond "Moi et Toi" Bypass Ring
The two-stone engagement ring will always be an eye-catching design. Add double the bling with this vintage rose-cut diamond ring.
Van Cleef & Arpels Frivole Between the Finger Ring
We're obsessed with how light and delicate this yellow gold floral ring appears on the finger. The delicate diamonds placed in the center of each flower is the perfect touch of shimmer.
Capuccine Grey Diamond Ring, Rough Diamond Ring
This is as down to earth as it gets. An iridescent rough diamond is in the most beautiful hue of soft grey. The yellow gold band adds a timeless yet striking touch that we're in love with.
Mejuri Italic Cluster Ring
The emerald-cut stone adds such a pretty touch to this delicate cluster ring. With its asymmetry and unintentional placement, this is perfect for the bride who is seeking something both unique and understated.
VimleshBadaya 9k/14k Solid Gold Multi Sapphire Cluster Engagement Ring
Hello color! This dainty yet vibrant cluster ring set on a gold band is like pure magic to the eyes. With multi-colored sapphire and white diamonds, you truly get a little bit of everything.
1stDibs French 1910s Diamond 18 Karat Yellow Gold Platinum You and Me Ring
We love a unique shape that offers such beautiful movement and dimension. This French design exudes an unexpected vintage flair to the tension setting.
Capucinne Yellow Gold Engagement Ring, Unique Engagement Ring
We are at a loss for words when it comes to this captivating cluster of multi-colored sapphire stones on this yellow gold band. It's safe to say that this one-of-a-kind piece is a work of art.
Brilliant Earth Sweeping Ivy Diamond Engagement Ring
This is such an ethereal spin on an open-designed engagement ring. Inspired by cascading vines of ivy, this 14k rose gold oval engagement ring effortlessly drapes across the finger.
1stDibs Four Leaf Clover 1.69 Carat Ruby and 0.40 Carat Diamonds 18 Karat Gold Band Ring
Sophisticated yet unexpected: a combination we didn't think could be achieved. A four leaf clover-shaped ruby is framed by a shimmering halo of diamonds on an 18k gold band.
Capucinne Isabella Tanzanite Engagement Ring, Statement Diamond Ring
This is so dreamy. A tanzanite is set in an elongated marquise-shaped stone framed by clusters of triangular bezel-set diamonds. We love how the yellow gold detail provides an eye-catching contrast against the dark center stone.
What to Look for When Choosing a Uniquely-Shaped Engagement Ring
The metal that is chosen for your forever ring can largely contribute to the distinct look of a uniquely-shaped engagement ring. You may decide to select a metal that blends in with your stone or acts as a sharp contrast. "For those with sensitivities, platinum is best. If you can wear yellow, rose, or white gold, consider the metal color that will complement your gemstone most," suggests Lorraine Brantner.
When it comes to the cut of your uniquely-shaped stone, it's usually best to play a little dress up! We won't argue with that. "Try on different center-stone shapes to see what looks best on your hand. You may like the look of a princess or cushion center stone in pictures, but find that you prefer how an oval or pear complements your finger," Brantner says.
"Consider your lifestyle and any jewelry that you already own," Brantner says. While uniquely-shaped engagement rings are undoubtedly striking and stunning, elaborate features may become obtrusive. Ensure that the cut and style of your engagement ring accommodates activities that you will regularly partake in when wearing your bling.
What is the most popular engagement ring style?
What are consistently the least popular engagement ring styles?
How can I make my engagement ring unique?
If you are looking for a truly eye-catching design, consider a halo with various fancy shapes or patterns surrounding your center stone. You can also go with a pear or marquise center stone for maximum finger coverage," Brantner says.