With a shadow brush, apply a neutral cream shadow, like beige, from lid to brow. Next, apply a darker shadow, like plum, in the crease; blend with a brush. Apply a medium highlighting color, like violet, under brow bone. Here: L’Oréal Paris Wear Infinité Long-Wearing Silky Powder Shadow in Shroom Shimmer, Plum Royale, and Violet Petal.
Apply black pencil in a thin line to upper lashes for more definition. Draw chocolate brown pencil liner inside lower lashes to soften the effect. Here: L’Oréal Paris HIP High Intensity Pigments Color Truth Eyeliner in Black (top) and Brown (bottom).
A double coat of lengthening black mascara will bring focus to the eyes and elongate lashes. To avoid the raccoon look, go with a waterproof formulation. Here: L’Oréal Paris Lash Architect Waterproof Mascara in Black.
Tip: To open up eyes and make lashes appear longer, use an eyelash curler before applying mascara.