The 30 Best Engagement Rings on Etsy

Everything from Vintage-Style to Nontraditional Gemstones

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Ring

Etsy

While engagement ring trends evolve at a slower pace than those of the regular fashion cycle, there's still plenty to keep up with in terms of what’s popular each year. Everything from unique diamond cuts to East-West and rose-gold settings are some of the most popular nontraditional styles while classic solitaire and three-stone rings are favored by many modern brides. It all depends on your aesthetic, which can certainly change over time, just as it does with the rest of the clothing and accessories in your wardrobe.

Meet the Expert

Dayna Isom Johnson is a trend expert at Etsy and judge on the NBC competition show, Making It.

Sometimes, a big part of the decision-making process is where you want to buy your engagement ring from and whether or not you want to work with a designer one-on-one to create a completely customized design. Of course, price is a major factor when it comes to shopping for an engagement ring, but whatever your budget or design preference is, there is a worldwide retailer that offers it all: Etsy.

Known for being the go-to retailer for unique and creative goods from around the globe from home décor, clothing, and party decorations to wedding-specific categories like flower crowns, invitations, bridesmaid gifts, and, of course, engagement rings. The website has everything under the sun from delicate and dainty styles to popular cushion-cut stones and baguette bands, as well as budget-friendly options like under-$1,5000 rings all the way to diamond alternatives like moissanite, morganite, white sapphires, and more.

“Brides are turning to more unique engagement ring styles and the trends speak to their interest in expressing their individuality and personal style,” says trend expert Dayna Isom Johnson. Popular bridal trends in ring choices are "all about putting a twist on traditional styles."

Whether you’re craving a custom design, ethically-sourced stone, or on-trend setting, ahead are 30 engagement rings from Etsy to consider.

01
of 30

Natural Ruby Engagement Ring Set with Marquise Diamond Crown Ring

Natural Ruby Engagement Ring Set with Marquise Diamond Crown Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This engagement ring from Etsy features a pear-shaped natural ruby for a center stone. It is accompanied by a matching marquise-cut diamond band.

02
of 30

Szeki Studio Natural Emerald Engagement Ring

Natural Emerald Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Emeralds are an eyecatching choice for an engagement ring stone, and this ring proves it. The natural emerald center stone is flanked by baguette-cut diamonds.

03
of 30

Sunday Island Sweden Diamond Opal Engagement Ring

Opal Wedding Rings Diamond Opal Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This dreamy ring features a natural Australian opal on a milgrain-detailed band.

04
of 30

Lillian James Jewelry Vintage Diamond and Diamond Accented Double Band Engagement Ring

Lillian James Jewelry Vintage Diamond and Diamond Accented Double Band Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Vintage from before 2000, this ring's diamond is held in a unique double band setting with diamond accents.

05
of 30

Capucinne Set of Emerald and Diamond Double Band Ring

Capucinne Set of Emerald and Diamond Double Band Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

The triple band on this engagement ring features an emerald held between two trillion cut diamonds. The top and bottom bands are a pavé style with rounded white diamonds. The middle band is an open matching ring.

06
of 30

Nangijala Jewelry Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Nangijala Jewelry Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This ring is handmade from gray palladium in combination with 14k rose gold. The center stone is a brown rose-cut diamond.

07
of 30

Oh Kuol Vintage Flower Aquamarine Engagement Ring Set

Oh Kuol Vintage Flower Aquamarine Engagement Ring Set

COURTESY OF ETSY

A double diamond scalloped band holds this ring's cushion-cut aquamarine center stone.

08
of 30

Capucinne Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring

Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring in Rose Gold From Capucinne

Etsy

For a simple, yet modern look consider this marquise-cut diamond ring with two trillion-cut diamonds on either side. The three stones are set on an 18k solid gold band.

09
of 30

Artemer Pear Diamond Engagement Ring & Diamond Band

Artemer Pear Diamond Engagement Ring & Diamond Band

COURTESY OF ETSY

This wedding ring set features a pear-shaped diamond engagement ring with a matching "V" shaped ring. Both are crafted in 18k solid gold.

10
of 30

Envero Jewelry Oval Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

Envero Jewelry Oval Rose Cut Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

For a vintage-inspired design, don't miss this oval rose-cut diamond ring with milgrain detailing.

11
of 30

Sarah Hood Jewelry Recycled 14k Rose and White Gold Twig Ring

Sarah Hood Jewelry Recycled 14k Rose and White Gold Twig Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

For an eco-friendly option, consider this recycled 14k rose and white gold ring with a twig design. The center stone is an oval moissanite.

12
of 30

The Copper Canary Antique Engagement Ring

The Copper Canary Antique Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Calling all antique lovers! This art-deco 1920s ring features a .60ct European cut diamond surrounded by filigree detailing.

13
of 30

Aardvark Jewellery Lab Grown Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

Aardvark Jewellery Lab grown diamond solitaire engagement ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

For a simple and understated look, this lab grown solitaire diamond is a great option. The rounded center stone is held on an art-deco floating style mount.

14
of 30

Aardvark Jewellery Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring

Aardvark Jewellery Lab Grown Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This lab grown diamond is a traditional style with a single solitaire stone held on a platinum band.

15
of 30

Artemer Art Deco Style Engagement Ring

Artemer Art Deco Style Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This art-deco style ring makes for a truly one-of-a-kind ring. Baguette-diamonds are set in a tapered gradient design on an 18k solid gold band.

16
of 30

Ny Fine Jewelry Vintage Morganite Engagement Ring

Vintage Morganite Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Morganite is a romantic option for an engagement ring stone. This morganite stone is held in a half halo of natural conflict-free diamonds.

17
of 30

EidelPrecious Blush Sapphire Engagement Ring

Eidel Precious Blush Sapphire Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This breathtaking ring features an oval blue sapphire stone accompanied by two round and one pear diamond accents.

18
of 30

MinimalVS Round Salt Pepper Diamond Engagement Ring

MinimalVS Round Salt Pepper Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Salt and pepper diamonds are an unexpected yet stunning alternative to traditional diamonds. This salt and pepper diamond is flanked by two rounded white diamonds.

19
of 30

Evorden Green Sapphire Engagement Ring

Evorden Green Sapphire Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Classic meshes with individualistic with this green sapphire engagement ring. The center stone is held between two pear, brilliant cut diamonds.

20
of 30

Designs by Kami Halo Princess Cut Engagement Ring

Designs by Kami Halo Princess Cut Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

There is no denying this split-shank engagement ring sparkles. The square modified brilliant cut center diamond is in a halo setting with a double pavé band.

21
of 30

MinimialVS Sunset Ring Set

MinimialVS Sunset Ring Set

COURTESY OF ETSY

This wedding ring set is unlike any other. The contrasting sunset design is made up of orange and blue genuine gemstones made in 14k or 18k solid gold.

22
of 30

Brockton Gems Modern Moi Et Toi Engagement Ring

Brockton Gems Modern Moi Et Toi Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

Inspired by Emily Ratajkowski's engagement ring, this toi et moi style ring features a brilliant cut pear shaped diamond and teal green radiant cut sapphire.

23
of 30

Wilson Brothers Yellow Gold Diamond Cluster Halo Engagement Ring

Wilson Brothers Yellow Gold Diamond Cluster Halo Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This vintage before 2000 engagement ring features a composite of square-cut diamonds set in a raised frame of gleaming white gold.

24
of 30

Keyzar Oval Engagement Ring

Keyzar Oval Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This delicate Moissanite engagement ring is set on a thin band sprinkled with moissanite diamonds.

25
of 30

MSJewelers Classic Solitaire, Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

MSJewelers Classic Solitaire, Vintage Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

We adore this dainty and retro engagement ring. The center stone is held in a box style illusion of white gold. The detailing on the band makes for an extra touch of elegance.

26
of 30

MSJewelers Classic Art Deco Moissanite Diamond Engagement Ring

MSJewelers Classic Art Deco Moissanite Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This elegant moissanite ring features an emerald cut center stone in a halo setting with a pavé band.

27
of 30

Olivia Ewing Jewelry Silver Montana Sapphire Naples Three Stone Ring

Olivia Ewing Jewelry Silver Montana Sapphire Naples Three Stone Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

For a splash of blue, this nontraditional stone engagement ring is the perfect option. This three stone ring includes Montana Sapphires in shades of blue, green and teal.

28
of 30

By Angeline Raw Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

By Angeline Raw Diamond Solitaire Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

A raw diamond sits in the middle of an 18k gold band with rustic detailing.

29
of 30

Hidden Space Jewelry Salt and Pepper Diamond Engagement Ring

Hidden Space Jewelry Salt and Pepper Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

The rose gold band contrasting this glittering art-deco ring is perfect for the bride who is looking for a distinct look. The kite-shaped salt and pepper diamond sits on top of a burst of marquise-cut diamonds

30
of 30

Jewelry by Garo Champagne Brown Diamond Engagement Ring

Jewelry by Garo Champagne Brown Diamond Engagement Ring

COURTESY OF ETSY

This champagne and white diamond ring is a truly timeless piece. The center diamond sits in a halo setting with four small rounded diamond accents. The split shank band makes for a striking design.

What to Look for When Purchasing an Engagement Ring From Etsy

Nontraditional Gemstones

Etsy is an excellent place to look for alternatives to the traditional diamond engagement ring. Johnson explains that on Etsy, nontraditional engagement rings are becoming increasingly popular. “For generations, the diamond has been the ultimate stone for proposing, but today’s bride isn’t tied to the norm—she wants to express her personal style and choose a ring that reflects her personality—which is why in the coming years, other gemstones will become go-to staples for engagement rings.

Etsy shoppers are ahead of the trend: We’ve already seen a rise in searches for nontraditional gemstone rings, from opals to sapphires. In [a scope of] three months alone, there have been over 1,500,000 searches for opals, 895,000 searches for emeralds, and 892,000 searches for sapphires. One trend in non-diamond engagement rings is incorporating birthstones. On Etsy, we’ve seen over 259,00 searches for ‘birthstone rings’ in the [scope of] three months, and I predict the trend will continue to grow for engagement rings,” Johnson says.

Lab-Grown and Vintage Diamonds

Lab-grown and vintage diamonds may be hard to seek out at traditional jewelers, but on Etsy there is a plethora of options. “On Etsy, we’ve seen a 66 percent increase in searches related to ‘lab-grown diamonds’ over the [scope of] 12 months (compared to the same time the previous year). If brides are not quite sold on recycled materials or lab-created diamonds, another option is to purchase a beautiful vintage sparkler from decades past. Vintage engagement rings are a favorite with shoppers on Etsy–we’ve seen 577,000 searches for them over the [scope of] 12 months," Johnson shares.

Sustainable Rings

Sustainable engagement rings are one option to consider when you are looking on Etsy. While there are many retailers that are beginning to offer sustainable rings, Etsy has a wide array of sustainable choices. Johnson explains how sustainable rings are becoming a common choice amongst brides.

“Shoppers are becoming increasingly conscious of their purchasing habits and we’ve seen sustainability on the rise across all categories, including jewelry. Brides are incorporating sustainable elements–from ethically-sourced diamonds to recycled metals–into their rings to make a statement without making a big impact on the planet.”

FAQs

  • How much do engagement rings on Etsy cost? Engagement rings on Etsy vary in price just the same as they would at any other jeweler. You can find rings from $200 to $20,000. It's all about what you are looking for in your ring.
  • Can you work directly with a jeweler on Etsy? Yes, it is possible to have a one-on-one experience with a jeweler on Etsy. "For an even more special experience, couples planning their engagement can work directly with many Etsy sellers to customize the ring to exactly what they have imagined," says Johnson.
  • How can you be sure you are getting a quality ring from an Etsy seller? When buying from Etsy, it's important to verify that the ring you're getting is a quality item. Try reading reviews on rings that you are considering to see how other customers' experiences with the seller were. Also, if you are buying a diamond engagement ring on Etsy, make sure to ask for the diamond's certification to ensure it is authentic. 

Related Stories