Lancôme Artliner Precision Point Eyeliner, $29
"I love the sleek finish of liquid liner, but it can be hard to apply. This one has a foam tip, which makes it super easy to use." —Abby, editorial assistant
Make Up For Ever Star Black Aqua Eyes Eyeliner, $17
"I don't have the steadiest hand, so I like that this gel-based liner is forgiving. It's also smudgeproof, long-lasting, and waterproof, but at the end of the day it comes off easily with a little makeup remover." —Cari, associate editor
Anastasia Beverly Hills Perfect Brow Pencil, $22
"When I went browsing for an eyebrow pencil, I was directed to Anastasia's Perfect Brow Pencil in the surprising shade of 'ash blonde'—even though I have auburn hair. This wins my award for 'best advice ever received from a salesperson at Sephora.'" —Julie, editor in chief
Lancôme Virtuose Black Carat Mascara, $24.50
"It wasn't easy to satisfy my list of mascara demands: 1) long, thick lashes (duh); 2) easy to put on without making a mess; 3) no smudging; and 4) comes off easily (keyword: easily) with soap and water. But this mascara can hold up to serious sob fests and sweaty dancing, plus, like it knows when its time is up, it gracefully disappears when you wash your face." —Julie
MAC 7 Lashes, $14
"It amazed me how much 'fake' I had to use to create a natural look for my wedding day—fake hair, fake tan, and yes, fake eyelashes. I was really skeptical when my makeup artist broke them out, but I was shocked at how lush and full they made my lashes look. And, I still felt like myself—with a hint of glam thrown in." —Kim, associate fashion editor
Becca Chantilly Eye Colour, $24
"On my skin, this slightly matte, slightly shimmery taupe is the perfect neutral. I use this seriously wearable shade as the base of any eye look I'm trying to achieve, and it works for everyday wear after the wedding is over." —Julie
Estée Lauder Graphite Double Wear Stay in Place Eye Pencil, $19
"I like smoky eyes, but black is too harsh with my pale complexion. Instead, I use this creamy charcoal-colored eye pencil, which comes with a smudger on one end for easy blending. It stays on forever—no need to worry about raccoon eyes." —Lauren, senior associate editor
Clinique Lash Power Long Wearing Formula Mascara, $14
"My number one priority with mascara is that it will last all day, and this one definitely does the trick. It can be a little tough to get off, but I've found that using warm water usually gets the job done." —Cari