An Expert Guide to Creating a Flavorful Fall Wedding Menu

Plus, nine dishes that are perfect for the season

Updated 10/02/19

Photo by Olivia Rae James

From warm color palettes to cozy vibes and rich flavors, fall weddings are all about embracing the season—and that goes for the food served as well! As temperatures drop and leaves begin to fall, the way we eat changes, so it's no surprise that caterers have noticed a difference in what couples are requesting for fall wedding fare.

To break down exactly what's different (and great!) about cocktail hour, dinner, and dessert menus this time of year, we called on top caterers to chat about everything from what guests want to what's in season. And, well, we learned a lot!

So if you're planning a fall wedding (in 2019 or 220), read on for a step-by-step guide to creating a fall wedding menu that's flavorful, creative, and comforting in all the season's best ways.

Think Less Stations, More Passed Apps

As the weather changes, weddings tend to start moving inside. There’s still a fair share of outside weddings in the fall, amongst the trees and the leaves, but the way we dine definitely has the tendency to change. “Cocktail hours traditionally start to drop off in the fall,” says Ryan Carey, Owner of Fire and Co. Wood-Fired Catering. “People tend to lean toward more small bites and passed apps rather than stations.”   

Consider Comfort Foods

Chillier weather definitely means more comfort food, and there’s nothing wrong with bringing these to the table. To accomplish this at your wedding, start by thinking about the foods you incorporate into your diet once summer is over and how you can serve those in a creative way. “In the fall, we are not serving as lite of fare as we see in July," Carey says. "We do less seafood and definitely more comfort food and more hearty foods like rotisserie chicken and smoked pork.”  

Embrace Seasonal Flavors

As with weddings any season, using what’s fresh is a great way to set your menu for the season—and, thankfully, fall has a lot of powerful, earthy flavors to incorporate. “We are always farm-to-table, so you want to see what's fresh and available and in-season,” says Davi Sobotta, Sales Manager for Foodz Catering. “Fall trends gravitate toward squashes, like your acorn, butternut, and delicata, along with pumpkins and yams. We also start working with more chutneys and deeper, richer sauces.”  

Break Out the Wood Fire

Everyone loves a bonfire on a cool night, so why not incorporate those warm, hearth flavors into your wedding menu for fall? “September and October are our busiest times of the year because of the wood-fired smells and flavors,” says Carey. “It speaks well for a fall dining experience and portrays itself much better in the cooler months.” According to Carey, wood-fired pizza stations are incredibly popular, as are smoked meats like a smoked brisket or doing a pig roast.  

Yum! To put these ideas into practice, we curated a list of nine flavorful dishes that are sure to impress every foodie on your guest list. Check them out below!

01 of 09

Charcuterie

charcuterie

Photo by Poor Girls Pantry

Charcuterie spreads are for every season! As the weather transitions to fall, consider bringing in heartier cheeses and incorporating seasonal fruits and veggies such as grapes, apples, and nuts.  

02 of 09

Empanadas

empandas
Photo by Alex Lau

Empanadas can be perfect any time of year, but when you incorporate flavors like black bean or squash, they're a perfect fit for fall. Plus, empanadas hold heat well, making them a warm and comfy app when served in a cool setting. 

03 of 09

Grilled Cheese Sandwiches and Tomato Soup

grilled cheese and tomato soup

Photo by Summer Street Photography

Nothing screams comfort food more than this go-to combo. Take this concept and elevate it at cocktail hour by pairing mini grilled cheese triangles with shot-size cups of tomato soup.  

04 of 09

Pulled Pork or Brisket Sliders

pork slider

 Photo by Karen Wise Photography

Since fall menus trend toward more passed apps, ask your caterer to do up a warm, smoky slider. The deep, maple flavors of smoked pork or brisket are perfect for fall.  

05 of 09

Cauliflower Mash or Sweet Potato Puree

sweet potato puree

Photo by Salt and Lavender 

At dinner, swap out your roasted fingerlings for a heartier, fall selection. We love the idea of incorporating a cauliflower mash or a sweet potato puree to bring in the warm flavors from fall harvest.  

06 of 09

Wood-Fired Pizzas

pizza bar

Photo by Alicia Lucia Photography

Pizza is a totally timeless and classic comfort food, and it can offer a flavor combo that all of your guests will love. Take your pizza offerings up a notch by bringing in a wood-fired oven to get that smoky, crispy crust.  

07 of 09

Roasted Brussel Sprouts

brussel sprouts

 Photo by Ambitious Kitchen

Brussels sprouts are quintessential fall vegetables, so incorporate this fresh, seasonal option in a roasted dish at dinner to bring out nature's earthy flavors.   

08 of 09

Meatball Skewers

meatballs

Photo by Belathee Photography 

Bring back the comfort of spaghetti and meatballs, without all the mess. To do this, ask your caterer to serve meatballs (dipped in warm, fall flavors) on skewers for easy eating at dinner or cocktail hour.

09 of 09

Chicken and Biscuits

<p>Wedding Appetizers</p>

Photo by Kate Headley

What says comfort food better than a warm biscuit? Get creative and serve this traditional breakfast food with chicken (and honey drizzle!) to end the night on a warm, seasonal note.

Related Stories