There are plenty of couples who feel that cake just isn’t their thing. And typically, alternatives such as cookies, pies, brownies, and donuts have been showing up on dessert tables to offer something a little different. But what if you have no sweet tooth at all? Enter cheesecake wedding cakes.
While a traditional cheesecake first comes to mind, there's also another iteration of this cake alternative. The new take? Tiered cakes made from wheels of cheese are the perfect way to incorporate that traditional stacked cake look while offering something different and wildly delicious.
Meet the Expert
Aleah and Nick Valley are the founders of Valley & Company Events, a wedding and event planning, design, and floral company based in Seattle, Washington.
“Keeping the tradition of a wedding cake but putting a personal stamp on the ceremony by serving a stacked cheese cake is a fun and creative way to show off the style and likes of a couple,” says Aleah and Nick Valley, founders of Valley & Company Events.
How to Set Up a Wheel Cheesecake For Your Wedding
When choosing cheeses for your cake, think about varieties that are a bit firmer. "Cheeses that are a bit firmer are successful because they hold up well and allow for stacking. If a couple loves a good triple creme brie or an herbed chèvre, we suggest saving that for the top tier as it will be much softer," says Aleah and Nick Valley.
Be sure to consider smellier cheeses, how those scents or flavors might interfere with others in the stack, and how you might decorate each wheel to complete the look. "What's even more elevated is dressing the cheese cake display with seasonal fruits," says Aleah and Nick Valley. "Whether it’s champagne grapes, figs, citrus, or stone fruits to complement the display, getting ultra-creative and bountiful with the accompanying presentation can be so memorable and fun!"
Serving a tiered cheese cake may require a bit of planning ahead of time, as it’s not quite the same as a traditional cake cutting. Aleah and Nick Valley suggest that the tiered cake be divided into smaller cheese blocks or wheels to serve at guest tables. Pair your cheeses with artisanal crackers, fresh fruits, fig jam, and honey to enhance the presentation and experience.
With so many choices, luckily, we’ve put together some cheesy inspiration to whet your appetite. Read on for 21 cheesecake wedding cakes—from traditional recipes to new on-the-wheel iterations—that will delight your guests.
Keep It Traditonal
Love cheesecake? There's no reason to stray from the forever favorite! This tiered creation is decorated with a drizzle of chocolate, raspberries, and gorgeous pink roses, proving that you can have your cake and eat it too.
Enhance the Cake
Upgrade a plain cheesecake by adding flavor—and edible flowers! Shown here with tiers of yellow, pink, and purple, this confection is any cheesecake lover's dream.
Layer Different Cheeses
This tiered cake is so pretty, it must have been hard to cut into. With layers of hard and soft cheeses, it certainly stood tall to make a delicious statement. But it’s the décor that really sealed the deal, adding florals and greenery and even bringing more cheese into the mix to decorate.
Tell a Story
Creating a cake out of cheese can offer the ideal opportunity to tell a story. Consider incorporating cheese options from countries you’ve traveled to together while creating a beautiful masterpiece. This cake incorporated dots of florals and fresh fruits to complete the look.
Add Fruit Accents
Adding bountiful, seasonal produce is such a gorgeous way to dress up a cake made out of cheese. The addition of fruits such as figs, berries, and apricots, with sprigs of greenery, perfectly finished the look of this beautiful cake.
Serve Individual Treats
Surprise guests by making them individual, bite-size cheesecakes. There's something special about the customization—plus, we think they'll enjoy the no-frills cutting and blueberry topping.
Decorate With Flowers
Talk about a pop of color! We love the way this tiered beauty incorporated cheese wheels in similar hues, adding a colorful statement with stunning florals.
Stick With Simple
The best thing about a cheesecake is that it doesn't need to be fancy. Here, fresh blooms and a chic cake stand to make this Costco cake (yes, really!) wedding-worthy.
Showcase Multiple Shapes
What a unique way to offer height and dimension to make a statement. Don’t be afraid to try a variety of cheeses before making your selections, as many might come in unique shapes. With six distinctive layers of cheese decked out with florals and stone fruits, this design is simply stunning.
Top With Honey
This stacked setup is an absolute dream. With layers of soft cheese topped with honeycomb and decked out with plump blackberries, the color palette that was used to pull this off is simply divine.
Decorate With Greenery
This stacked cheesecake was so simple, yet stunning. We love the way harder cheeses were featured on the bottom with softer options on top. And the sweet additions of greenery, thistle, and white roses are absolutely beautiful.
Make it Mini
Not in love with the tall-tiered cake look? There’s a cheese cake for that too! This set-up incorporated a mini cheesecake, paired with fresh fruits and greenery. The display also incorporated additional triangles of cheese with crostini for easy service.
Pair With Charcuterie
What if you took a cake made out of cheese and paired it with additional meats and delicious spreads? Talk about a charcuterie dream come true. We love the way this cake was incorporated into a dessert table complete with pies and cheesecake to offer a mixture of sweet and savory options for every guest.
Flourish With Fruit
Cheese cakes truly have the potential to fit any palette, whether it’s with simple white hues or making a bold statement with color. This cake is stacked with a variety of cheeses, paired with grapes, strawberries, and figs, to offer a little something for everyone.
Embrace a Vineyard Vibe
This cake balanced modern and rustic in the most beautiful way. Setting the cheese cake on top of a barrel made for such a gorgeous rustic look, paired with grapes to bring together a farm or vineyard vibe.
Get a Little Cheesy
The cake topper said it all for this stunning cake. We love this fun addition, adding a bit of humor, but it might be the simple décor that really takes the cake. Pairing rosemary, lavender, and white lilacs, this was such a lovely design.
Bring In Unexpected Height
This cheesecake setup switched up the typical rule of having hard cheeses on the bottom tier, offering a huge wheel of soft cheese. If your favorite cheese is brie and you want to serve more of that than anything else, don’t be afraid to ask your caterer or planner to see if they can pull it off. This option added structure above the first layer for additional layers to sit on top of.
Consider Colorful Contrasts
Be sure your guests know exactly what they’re getting with cute little markers on each tier. We love the way these cheese wheels were stacked to add contrast and paired perfectly with accenting figs, grapes, and thistles.
Channel Rustic Elegance
Cheese cakes might just be the best way to capture rustic elegance, and this cake pulled it off perfectly. With hard and soft cheese options, and even some with a bit of a rind, this cake offers a cheese every guest will love. And with the addition of greenery and roses, surrounded by candlelight, it was magically beautiful.
Top With Figs and Rosemary
With French dauphinoise and rosemary manchego, the base of this tiered cheese cake provided a gorgeous opportunity for simple décor. Fresh figs and rosemary sprigs add a pop of rustic color, with a piece of honeycomb to round out the look.
Finish With Florals
Have you ever seen cheese look so elegant? This four-tiered cheese cake was beautifully decorated with gorgeous white blooms and a touch of greenery to bring the look together.
Skip the Cake Stand
Keep it simple but still stunning by forgoing the cake stand for a simple plate or charger. This cheese cake is set on a black plate, giving the creation some dramatic flair.
Add Seasonal Touches
Choosing an untraditional wedding cake doesn't mean you can't add seasonal touches to your cheese cake. Check out this design that includes berries, fruits, and dried herbs, which would look work well at a fall wedding.
Offer Unexpected Flavors
You can add the unexpected to mini cheesecakes by choosing original flavors. These are topped with an eggnog filling, perfect for a holiday wedding.
Serve Multiple Varieties
Guests love variety, so why not serve single cheesecakes with different toppings and flavors? This way, everyone can sample multiple options.
Top It With a Heart
Add some whimsy to basic tiers of cheese by adding a heart to the top tier. Bonus points if the heart is also made of cheese!