Best Cookie Delivery Services of 2021

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Whether you’re looking for a great way to say, “Will you be my bridesmaid?” or “Thanks for coming to my nuptials,” or you just need to stress eat before the big day, the ante is up on the cookie game. After vigorous research and much drooling, these are the best cookie delivery services of 2021.

There are a lot of pros to ordering from a cookie delivery service: You can customize your packaging, save time picking up, and accommodate dietary restrictions for your vegan and gluten-free friends. But which is the best service? We’ve done the research to help you find the best cookie delivery service.

Best Cookie Delivery Services of 2021

Best Overall: The Finer Cookie
Best for Gourmet: Cravory Cookies
Best for Special Occasions: Southern Sugar Bakery
Best for Allergen-Free: Karma Baker
Best for Organic: Bang Cookies

Best Overall: The Finer Cookie

Why We Chose It

There are tons of bakeries in the U.S. now, but most specialize in one type of cookie or another. The Finer Cookie offers inventive gourmet drop cookie flavors as expected, but it also has various other styles, such as shortbread and madeleines. Plus, its packaging elevates them to a giftable level.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Huge variety
Beautiful packaging
Free shipping with about a $75 order
A fair number of gluten-free options

Cons

Few vegan options
Upcharge for different colored packaging

What makes a cookie great? There are varying opinions, of course, but when it comes to giftable cookies, variety comes in as a top priority. The Finer Cookie, based in Montreal, Quebec, offers delectable flavors of chewy drop cookies like chocolate brownie as well as different cookie styles like rosemary shortbread with vodka and cardamom or coconut macaroons with lime and cinnamon.

Although not dedicated to special dietary restrictions, The Finer Cookie does offer several gluten-free offerings, but only two vegan options. Since each cookie comes individually wrapped, you can mix and match in batches of six to create a perfect box.

Prices start at about $14 for six cookies when building a custom box, or you can order preselected packs. The Finer Cookie delivers all over the U.S. and Canada, and shipping is free for orders over about $75. Plus, the packaging screams indulgence with a glossy black box that protects the precious contents inside. You can even customize the color of the box for a small upcharge.

Best for Gourmet: Cravory Cookies

Why We Chose It

Sometimes you feel like chocolate chip. And sometimes you feel like rosemary balsamic, mango con chile, or ube. With Cravory Cookies, you can have it all.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Inventive flavors with six new flavors monthly
Reviews of each flavor on the website
Cookie of the month club
Custom wedding cookies available

Cons

Very few vegan or gluten-free options
Only drop cookies; no other varieties

If you want inventive flavors, adorable packaging, and oven-fresh flavor, Cravory Cookies from San Diego might be just the thing. Since its inception in 2009, Cravory has created more than 5,000 unique cookie flavors, with more coming all the time.

Cravory specializes in drop cookies, so their value is in the flavor combinations, and they knock it out of the park. If you want to try some of their more unique flavors, order the Adventurous mix for roughly $17, which includes two each of their cookies ‘n cream milkshake, pancakes and bacon, peanut butter overload, chocolate truffle, rosemary balsamic, and taro. Or, make a custom dozen with whatever tickles your fancy.

Planning your big day? Whether you’re getting married, hosting a shower, or planning a day before brunch, Cravory Cookies can package cookies for favors or welcome boxes, complete with ribbon and personalized name and date tags.

Best for Special Occasions: Southern Sugar Bakery

Why We Chose It

If you’re mesmerized by cookie decorating videos like we are, you’ll love Southern Sugar. Each cookie is a work of art.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Choose from design collections or customize
Variety of decorated sugar cookies or drop cookies

Cons

No gluten-free or vegan options
Must order a week in advance
Fairly expensive

There are two levels of favors at weddings and events: the favors that commemorate the couple or day that end up in the trash after a week at home and the favors that are gobbled up immediately. If you want the latter, Southern Sugar Bakery is the obvious choice.

This North Carolina-based bakery has grown from a hobby for two high school classmates to one of the most sought-after bakeries in the country. It is so in demand that it does sell out, so order early to get beautiful and intricately decorated sugar cookies for your wedding, shower, or bridal brunch. Not concerned with the aesthetic? Southern Sugar also offers classic drop cookies.

Of course, beautiful craftsmanship comes at a price—around $54 for a dozen sugar cookies. However, once you see the artistry in each hand-iced cookie, the cost is justified. Plus, customization is included in any of the event collections.

Best for Allergen-Free: Karma Baker

Why We Chose It

Whether you’re vegan or have dietary restrictions such as egg or gluten allergies, the land of cookies can be a minefield. All of Karma Baker’s cookies are vegan and gluten-free for a safe and delicious indulgence.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Allergen-free
Good variety of decorated and drop cookies
Also offers cakes, cupcakes, and cake pops
Some varieties support charity

Cons

Fairly expensive
May have nut contamination
Not individually wrapped

For vegans or those with gluten allergies, cookies may seem elusive. Karma Baker out of Los Angeles wants to change that. All of their cookies, cakes, and cupcake jars are gluten-free and vegan, and according to their rave reviews, they’re also delicious.

Karma Baker specializes in recreating the cookies that so many crave but can’t have, including its karma cookies, which give Oreos a run for their money, or any of its sandwich cookies. It even offers decorated sugar cookies in seasonal designs for the holidays.

Since Karma Baker only makes vegan cookies, those with milk or egg allergies are entirely safe to enjoy. However, the bakery notes that while it has nut-free cookies, they are made in the same space as their nut-full varieties, so those with extreme allergies should abstain.

Vegan and gluten-free cookies come at a cost, and the Cookie Karma box, which includes three karma cookies, three oatmeal chai sandwich cookies, and three chocolate chip-wich cookies, retails for about $54. But the cookies are also jumbo-sized so that the pleasure will last a little longer.

Best for Organic: Bang Cookies

Why We Chose It

Bang Cookies are giant, soft-baked cookies like mom used to make if mom only used organic, natural ingredients with no GMOs.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Huge variety of flavors, including stuffed and boozy cookies
Huge sizes
Fast shipping
All-natural and organic ingredients
Loyalty program

Cons

No gluten-free options, although they are developing recipes
No special boxing for presentation

When the craving for cookies hits, health may not be at the top of your mind. However, George Kuan, founder of Bang Cookies, believes that even indulgences should have quality ingredients. Bang Cookies makes the most of this ethos with giant, soft-baked cookies in delectable flavors made with all organic ingredients, right down to the grass-fed butter from New Zealand.

Not only does Bang Cookies use high-quality ingredients, but they also keep innovation at the forefront. In addition to classic flavors like sea salt chocolate chunk, it offers boozy varieties like bourbon kitchen sink, which has organic toffee bits and organic pretzel chunks with organic bourbon in a chocolate chunk cookie base. Or, try the stuffed cookies like the PB&J, which is filled with peanut butter and strawberry jam in a peanut butter cookie skin.

Bang Cookies have a huge following both in New Jersey and around the country, where fans get their fix via FedEx. Each giant-sized cookie is sold individually at about $5, so you can mix and match to your heart’s content. While they don’t come in a glossy box like many of the delivery services, they are individually packaged.

Final Verdict

Cookies delivery services are like sending a hug to someone through the mail (even if that person is yourself!). Even better? They can offer custom packaging or decoration for weddings and special occasions. With so many options to choose from, The Finer Cookie stands above the rest with its posh presentation and sheer diversity of cookies, from chewy drop cookies to shortbread to shaped favorites.

If you’re looking to wow at a brunch or send home favors that are truly appreciated, Southern Sugar creates beautiful cookies that can be customized to your theme. For sheer deliciousness, Cravory Cookies and Bang Cookies have you covered with high-quality ingredients, inventive flavor combos, and nationwide accessibility. And your vegan and gluten-free friends will feel seen and appreciated when they receive a special box from Karma Baker.

How to Choose the Best Cookie Delivery Services

Cookies are as individual as the people who enjoy them. In terms of budget, some services price their goods by the cookie, while others sell in batches of six or 12 cookies. Also, keep in mind delivery timetables. Some bakeries need up to a week of advanced notice, plus shipping time. Others can ship the same day.

And of course, review your dietary needs. If vegan, gluten-free, or organic cookies are a priority, check out the bakery's FAQ page. Most will be upfront about whether there are allergens or special dietary measures taken.

Cookie Delivery Services vs. In-Person Shopping

Cookie delivery services offer the convenience of online shopping, which can really help when planning an event. Many offer customizable packaging options that feature your color scheme or logo. While convenient, most cookie delivery services do charge shipping unless it’s a large order which can seriously raise the overall price of the purchase. Ordering online also allows you to choose from bakeries across the nation.

In-person shopping allows you to see what is appealing up close, and there’s nothing better than a warm cookie fresh from the oven. You’ll save on shipping costs but if you’re hoping for custom packaging, you may still have to order ahead and pick up.

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Do Cookie Delivery Services Cost?

Cookie delivery services vary in price from about $5 for a single cookie to up to roughly $60 for a custom box. Shipping is often extra unless you hit a purchase threshold. This will vary from one bakery to another as well.

Do Cookie Delivery Services Provide Gifting Options?

Some cookie delivery services provide gifting options such as messages included or elevated packaging. Inquire with your specific bakery to confirm.

Methodology

When looking for the best cookie delivery services, our team considered dozens of bakeries around the nation. All of our selections had to ship nationwide and with fast delivery times in order to keep cookies fresh. We sought out bakers that provide a variety of options for all, including those with dietary restrictions.