Best Cookie Delivery Services

What makes a cookie great? There are varying opinions, of course, but when it comes to giftable cookies, variety comes in as a top priority. The Finer Cookie, based in Montreal, Quebec, offers delectable flavors of chewy drop cookies like chocolate brownie as well as different cookie styles like rosemary shortbread with vodka and cardamom or vanilla ice wine tea. 

Although not dedicated to special dietary restrictions, The Finer Cookie does offer several gluten-free offerings, but only two vegan options. Since each cookie comes individually wrapped, you can mix and match in batches of six to create a perfect box. 

Prices start at about $14 for six cookies when building a custom box, or you can order preselected packs. The Finer Cookie delivers all over the U.S. and Canada, and shipping is free for orders over about $85. Plus, the packaging screams indulgence with a glossy black box that protects the precious contents inside. You can even customize the color of the box for a small upcharge. 

If you want inventive flavors, adorable packaging, and oven-fresh flavor, Cravory Cookies from San Diego might be just the thing. Since its inception in 2009, Cravory has created more than 5,000 unique cookie flavors, with more coming all the time. 

Cravory specializes in drop cookies, so their value is in the flavor combinations, and they knock it out of the park. If you want to try some of their more unique flavors, order the Adventurous mix for roughly $19, which includes two each of their cookies ‘n cream milkshake, pancakes and bacon, peanut butter overload, chocolate truffle, rosemary balsamic, and taro. Or, make a custom dozen with whatever tickles your fancy. 

Planning your big day? Whether you’re getting married, hosting a shower, or planning a day before brunch, Cravory Cookies can package cookies for favors or welcome boxes, complete with ribbon and personalized name and date tags. 

There are two levels of favors at weddings and events: the favors that commemorate the couple or day that end up in the trash after a week at home and the favors that are gobbled up immediately. If you want the latter, Southern Sugar Bakery is the obvious choice. 

This North Carolina-based bakery has grown from a hobby for two former high school counselors to one of the most sought-after bakeries in the country. It is so in demand that it does sell out, so order early to get beautiful and intricately decorated sugar cookies for your wedding, shower, or bridal brunch. Not concerned with the aesthetic? Southern Sugar also offers classic drop cookies. 

Of course, beautiful craftsmanship comes at a price—from $60 for a dozen sugar cookies. However, once you see the artistry in each hand-iced cookie, the cost is justified. Plus, customization is included in any of the event collections. 

For vegans or those with gluten allergies, cookies may seem elusive. Karma Baker out of Los Angeles wants to change that. All of their cookies, cakes, and cupcake jars are gluten-free and vegan, and according to their rave reviews, they’re also delicious. 

Karma Baker specializes in recreating the cookies that so many crave but can’t have, including its karma cookies, which give Oreos a run for their money, or any of its sandwich cookies. It even offers decorated sugar cookies in seasonal designs for the holidays. 

Since Karma Baker only makes vegan cookies, those with milk or egg allergies are entirely safe to enjoy. However, the bakery notes that while it has nut-free cookies, they are made in the same space as their nut-full varieties, so those with extreme allergies should abstain. 

Vegan and gluten-free cookies come at a cost, and the Sampler Karmabox, which includes one chocolate cake pop, one large fudge brownie, two donuts, two big fresh baked cookies, and three jumbo sandwich cookies, retails for about $54. But the cookies are also jumbo-sized so that the pleasure will last a little longer. 

When the craving for cookies hits, health may not be at the top of your mind. However, George Kuan, founder of Bang Cookies, believes that even indulgences should have quality ingredients. Bang Cookies makes the most of this ethos with giant, soft-baked cookies in delectable flavors made with all organic ingredients, right down to the grass-fed butter from New Zealand. 

Not only does Bang Cookies use high-quality ingredients, but they also keep innovation at the forefront. In addition to classic flavors like sea salt chocolate chunk, it offers varieties like kitchen sink, which has organic toffee bits and organic pretzel chunks in a chocolate chunk cookie base. Or, try the stuffed cookies like the PB&J, which is filled with peanut butter and strawberry jam in a peanut butter cookie skin. 

Bang Cookies have a huge following both in New Jersey and around the country, where fans get their fix via FedEx or UPS. Each giant-sized cookie is sold individually for $5-$6, so you can mix and match to your heart’s content. While they don’t come in a glossy box like many of the delivery services, they are individually packaged.