Best Chocolate Subscription Boxes

Compartes is the best overall chocolate subscription box.

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

Best Chocolate Subscription Boxes

Brides / Designed by Amelia Manley

When it comes to selecting gifts for your wedding party, there are so many options available. Sure, you could go with something monogrammed, but in terms of sheer enjoyment, consumables win the day. Enter the chocolate subscription box (also known as monthly bliss). 

There are tons of subscription boxes to choose from but we did the hard work researching the best chocolate subscription boxes of 2021. These all offer variety, easy shipping, and variable terms depending on your budget and will surely bring a smile to any sweet tooth's face.

Best Chocolate Subscription Boxes of 2021

Best Overall: Compartes

Compartes Chocolate of the Month

Compartes Chocolate of the Month

Why We Chose It 

When it comes to sheer variety, Compartes' Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club is the best, delighting the receiver with unique flavors of bars, bons-bons, and truffles for 12 months. 

Pros & Cons 

Pros

  • Themed boxes each month, coinciding with holidays
  • Variety of formats including truffles and bars
  • Exclusive flavors
  • Discount for longer-term

Cons

  • No customization 
  • No guarantee of dairy-free options

When you want a little bit of everything, Compartes’ Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club is a great fit. Compartes has a reputation for excellence with celebrity fans like Mindy Kaling, Antoni Porowski, Oprah, and Gwyneth Paltrow. After 70 years of experience, they are still on the cutting edge of flavor innovation with decadent flavor combinations like Caramelized Popcorn Milk Chocolate Bar or Pink Elephants Dark Chocolate Bar.  

Their chocolate of the month club delivers its diversity of flavors one theme at a time. For 12 months, it shares collections that center around a theme such as Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day, or seasonal themes such as summer berries or mystery flavors of pie. 

The club is available in three-month increments, with a slight price break available for longer terms. Chocoholics will receive a selection of chocolate bars or truffles with a value that far exceeds their cost of about $150 for a three-month membership, roughly $280 for six months, or around $500 for a year. Standard shipping is free, but expedited shipping is available for an additional fee. 

Best for Innovative Flavors: Raaka Chocolate

Raaka Chocolate

Raaka Chocolate

Why We Chose It 

Raaka Chocolate prides itself on creating unique flavors all the time. Its First Nibs Club allows members to experience new flavors of micro-batch chocolate bars first. 

Pros & Cons 

Pros 

  • Unique, gourmet flavors
  • Dairy and refined sugar-free options
  • Transparent-trade focused
  • Unroasted chocolate for a unique flavor 

Cons

  • Unroasted chocolate may taste different to some people
  • Small amount, only two or three bars per box
  • No customization

For many, single-origin chocolate is the highest echelon of quality. But what if a chocolatier used single-origin chocolates and innovative flavor additions? Well, you’d have Raaka Chocolate. Their head chocolatier, Nate Hodge, is constantly testing new flavor combos, and their First Nibs Club gets you first dibs. 

Raaka’s take on flavor additions takes an organic approach. You won’t find pop rocks in any of their bars, but you might find a gluten-free whole grain waffle cone embedded in single-origin Ugandan chocolate or green tea crunch. Raaka also uses unroasted chocolate beans for a brighter, fruitier flavor that separates them from many other chocolatiers. 

Members can choose between a two- or three-bar membership. With the three-bar option, members receive two of Raaka’s newest flavor innovations, as well as a bestseller from their current collection that syncs with the month’s theme. Nostalgic desserts were a recent theme and included a double chocolate waffle cone bar, strawberry peach cobbler bar, and a bananas foster bar. 

The First Nibs Club is available on a rolling basis at about $23 for two bars or roughly $28 for three bars with free shipping, but gift subscriptions are available in three-, six-, and 12-month increments, complete with a handwritten note from the company.

Best for Dark Chocolate: Bar and Cocoa

Bar and Cocoa

Bar and Cocoa

Why We Chose It 

Bar and Cocoa don’t mess around with milk or white chocolate. Its Dark Chocolate Club brings the best of dark chocolate to you from makers around the world. 

Pros & Cons 

Pros

  • Variety of makers
  • Free shipping
  • Eco-friendly packaging
  • Typically hard-to-get bars
  • All bars are gluten and dairy-free

Cons

  • Only plain bars
  • No sugar-free options 
  • No customization 

When only the deepest, darkest chocolate will do, the Dark Chocolate Club from Bar and Cocoa is ready to spring into action. Their club is single-minded in its purpose: to bring you the best quality dark chocolate from quality makers around the world. 

The club features four bars per month, available in three, six, or twelve-month terms, all with free shipping. A three-month subscription is roughly $129, and unless canceled, will auto-renew. Longer-term memberships offer a price break at about $249 for six months or roughly $489 for a full year. While some chocolate subscription boxes focus on wild flavors or whimsical add-ins, the Dark Chocolate Club focuses on the pure flavor of unadulterated dark chocolate. Some bars may only have two ingredients: cacao and sugar. 

Each bar comes with tasting notes to help guide members through their taste experience. Bar and Cocoa highlights makers that practice direct trade and ethical manufacturing practices, so your indulgence is good for you, the farmers, and the planet. 

Best for Dairy-Free: Cococlectic

Cococlectic

Cococlectic

Why We Chose It 

The pros at Cococletic curate four bars from small-batch producers around the world. All of its featured bars use only three ingredients: cacao beans, sugar, and cocoa butter. 

Pros & Cons

Pros 

  • All vegan options
  • Supports small producers
  • Monthly options

Cons

  • Unavailable in July and August
  • No customization

Bean-to-bar chocolate is one of the few foods in which dairy is entirely optional. All of the purveyors featured in the Cococletic chocolate subscription are dairy-free, making them vegan, and soy-free, gluten-free, and tree-nut-free as well. In fact, every maker featured uses five ingredients or fewer in its bars. 

The Cococletc chocolate club features four bars in each delivery, billing either monthly (the Sweet Devotee for about $43) or every three or six months (Bon Bon Vivant for roughly $122 or Coco’nnoisseur for around $245). One drawback of Cococletic is its yearly pause; the service doesn’t ship anything during July and August. 

For those who want to share their chocolate passion with their family or office, the company also offers an office box, which features 10 bars every month for about $99 per month. Domestic shipping is included in every subscription, but additional charges may apply if ice packs are needed for warm destinations. 

Best for Sugar-Free: The Good Chocolate

The Good Chocolate

The Good Chocolate

Why We Chose It 

While many chocolate makers use coconut sugar or other naturally derived sugars, The Good Chocolate contains zero sugar and less than one net carb per square. 

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Truly sugar-free
  • Customizable with favorite flavors
  • Variety pack available 
  • All organic ingredients

Cons 

  • Only available in six-month terms
  • Charges shipping under roughly $45

When the term "sugar-free" is thrown out in confectioners’ circles, there’s a lot of wiggle room. While many chocolate makers now use coconut sugar, maple, or honey, as far as calories and carbs are concerned, they're still sugar. Not The Good Chocolate. This Keto- and diabetic-friendly chocolate is sweetened with Stevia, Erythritol, and mesquite powder, making chocolate that logs less than two net carbs per square. 

Amazingly, The Good Chocolate does all this without sacrificing quality or taste and uses all organic ingredients. Its monthly subscription club features 18.4-ounce squares of chocolate in one of its signature flavors: signature dark, Himalayan salt, salted almonds, milk chocolate, mint, or ginger; or opt for a variety pack that features three squares of each. 

The subscription service is only available in six-month increments and is the most affordable club on this list at about $30 per month for six months. The only downside to that low price? It doesn’t qualify for free shipping, which adds roughly another $8. Still, for those with dietary restrictions, this club is worth the cost.

Final Verdict 

For all-around variety, Compartes Gourmet Chocolate of the Month Club offers fun themes and plenty to explore. As a longstanding company, it knows its niche, and celebrities and foodies alike recognize its dominance in the field of artisanal chocolate. 

If unique flavor combinations are your goal, Raaka Chocolate is on the cutting edge. Dark chocolate lovers will gravitate to Bar and Cocoa for its commitment to finding craft producers. There are many dairy-free options in the world of bean-to-bar chocolate, but Cococlectic makes it a focus. For truly sugar-free chocolates, The Good Chocolate cuts the carbs but leaves the satisfaction.

How to Choose the Best Chocolate Subscription Boxes

When looking for a chocolate subscription box, first decide what you enjoy. Do you want bars of chocolate or truffles? Then choose your focus: Do you want something that focuses on small producers or eco-friendly brands? Do you have dietary restrictions? Lastly, consider your budget. Most subscription services offer a slight discount for longer terms. Also, check to make sure shipping is included.

Chocolate Subscription Boxes vs. In-Store Shopping 

Chocolate subscription boxes add an element of surprise to your monthly chocolate indulgences. Many services include bars that are hard to find in stores or are from up-and-coming chocolate makers. While in-store shopping gives you the ability to choose your bars, your selection will be limited.

Frequently Asked Questions 

Do Chocolate Subscription Boxes Provide More Exclusive Flavors?

Many chocolate subscription boxes offer selections that are not available for regular purchase. For some makers, such as Raaka, its club members get the first taste of exclusive flavors that may not make it into the everyday lineup. 

Do Chocolate Subscription Boxes Offer Dairy-Free, Sugar-Free, or Vegan Options? 

Many chocolate makers offer dairy-free and vegan options simply because dairy isn’t necessary to make chocolate, especially dark chocolate. Even milk chocolate can now be made with oat or coconut milk for a creamy mouthfeel. Some chocolate makers use coconut sugar or sweeteners like maple syrup or honey in place of refined white sugar. There are even truly sugar-free options such as The Good Chocolate. 

How Much Do Chocolate Subscription Boxes Cost?

Chocolate subscription boxes typically start around $30 to $40 per month, depending on how many bars or truffles are included in each delivery. 

Methodology 

To find the best chocolate subscription services, we looked for bean-to-bar programs that focus on quality ingredients and ethical and sustainable practices. We evaluated 50 different services to find the most delicious offerings with convenient delivery schedules and fair pricing.

Related Stories