Best Cake Delivery Services

We Take the Cake is the best overall cake delivery service.

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

dessert table of mixed chocolate cake and berry cakes at a smaller wedding celebration in a backyard in sumer july

Shaw Photography Co. / Getty Images

Is there anything better than a slice of pillowy soft cake topped with whipped buttercream frosting? The only thing that comes close is having that perfect slice delivered to your doorstep. For the freshest, most drool-worthy cakes, we’ve found the best cake delivery services of 2021. 

Although you undoubtedly have your favorite hometown baker, sometimes ordering a cake for delivery makes sense. If you’re looking for a way to wow your future in-laws, or want to make your bridal party feel special from across the country, these cake delivery services will make an impression. 

Best Cake Delivery Services of 2021

Best Overall: We Take the Cake

We Take the Cake

We Take the Cake

Why We Chose It 

Whether you’re looking for a birthday cake, groom’s cake, or just something to wow a client or coworker, We Take the Cake has something for everyone. With various bundt cakes, layer cakes, and cupcakes, it offers easy ordering, and shipping is included in the price. 

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Huge variety
  • Shipping included in the listed price
  • Gluten-free and vegan options
  • Fresh ingredients

Cons

  • Some varieties only available for pickup
  • No custom cakes
  • Not suitable for nut allergies or celiac disease

In a sea of specialty bakers, We Take The Cake does a lot of things well. Its vast menu of cakes includes Oprah’s favorite, key lime bundt cake, as well as every type of layer cake and birthday cake you can imagine. 

Although the service focuses on the taste of its cakes, We Take the Cake also keeps aesthetics in mind. Beautifully piped buttercream adorns many of the company's creations, with options for fondant designs as well. Fair warning: Not all of its fondant or specialty cakes can be shipped, so read the fine print before ordering. 

Because so much of their business is online, We Take the Cake is upfront with its pricing. Most layer cakes clock in at about $79, including two-day shipping and specialty packaging with five pounds of dry ice. If you live in Fort Lauderdale, you can pick up your cake and eliminate roughly $24 in shipping fees. All cakes come packaged in the signature green and black presentation boxes for the extra "wow" factor. 

We Take the Cake also offers gluten-free and vegan cakes, but states that it can’t completely eliminate cross-contamination for those with severe allergies. It also uses nuts in some of its cakes, so those with nut allergies should be aware.

Best for Birthday Cakes: Carousel Cakes

Carousel Cakes

Carousel Cakes

Why We Chose It 

Carousel Cakes offers classic favorites like carrot spice layer cakes or several festive sprinkle cakes, including the chocolate "giggle" cake, filled with pastel buttercream and covered with nonpareil sprinkles. The variety and vibrancy make them perfect for any birthday celebration. 

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Fast shipping through Goldbelly
  • Lots of variety with sprinkle and funfetti cakes
  • Certified kosher

Cons

  • No gluten-free or vegan options
  • No customization

Maybe it’s our inner child talking, but there are sprinkles involved when we think of birthday cake. Lots of sprinkles. Carousel Cakes, located in New York and New Jersey, delivers on the sprinkle promise with gusto. 

With delivery through Goldbelly, Carousel Cakes has a wide variety of cakes. Choose the lightly frosted three-layer funfetti cake or go all-in with the sprinkle "Happy" cake. The sprinkles don’t stop there. It also features Oprah’s favorite red velvet cake and a strawberry crunch parfait cake, among others. 

Most cakes are about $49 with roughly an additional $35 in shipping through Goldbelly. They serve six to 10 people each and arrive on dry ice, ready to thaw for immediate enjoyment or freeze for up to three months. Note that Carousel Cakes only ships Monday through Thursday, so plan accordingly. 

Best for Customizable Cakes: Carlo’s Bakery

Carlo’s Bakery

Carlo’s Bakery

Why We Chose It 

They may call Buddy Valastro the "Cake Boss," but when you order from his family bakery, Carlo’s, you call the shots with their custom cake builder. 

Pros & Cons

Pros 

  • Custom cake builder is easy to use
  • Wide variety of designs
  • Single tier cakes feed 20-25 people

Cons

  • Not made in a nut or gluten-free environment
  • No gluten-free options
  • For truly custom orders, a consultation is needed

Say what you will about TV chefs, but Buddy Valastro has taken his family business, Carlo’s Bake Shop, to new heights. Since 1910, the Hoboken bakery has been churning out sweet treats for locals, and now you can choose from one of his vibrant designs. 

Although Carlo’s has expanded to 10 locations nationwide, fans can also build their cake using the custom cake builder on the website. Choose your event or decoration (we like the Sweet Dreams 2 Tier Cake) and then customize by choosing the flavor of your top tier, bottom tier, and the color of the icing used for the inscription on the cake board. And yes, you can have Carlo’s trademark vanilla rainbow cake as your cake flavor for visual punch. 

Carlo’s Bake Shop creations aren’t cheap, but the price of about $200 for a two-tier cake includes FedEx shipping. They are also sizable cakes, with a single tier serving 20 to 25 people and a two-tier serving 35 to 40 people. If you're looking for a great deal, Buddy and the Carlo’s team delivers.

Best for Food Sensitivities: Caroline’s Cakes

Caroline’s Cakes

Caroline’s Cakes

Why We Chose It 

Caroline’s Cakes offers a vast array of delicious southern comfort favorites, all made in a certified nut-free facility. With additional gluten-free options, Caroline’s makes it easy to accommodate those with allergies. 

Pros & Cons

Pros 

  • Recognized by the Food Allergy Initiative 
  • Uncommon southern favorites like caramel cake
  • Extensive selection of gluten-free options

Cons 

  • Gluten-free options are made in a facility that uses gluten, so possibilities of cross-contamination
  • Shipping rates are variable based on weight and location

Some bakeries make allergen-free cakes their focus. And then there are Caroline’s Cakes. All of the baked goods at Caroline’s are baked in a nut-free facility, but the focus is on that indulgent southern flavor. 

Caroline’s focuses on layer cakes—lots of layers. Her seven-layer caramel cake is the one that made her famous, and for a good reason. With seven layers of moist yellow cake sandwiched between layers of caramel icing, this is an indulgent treat that screams for a veranda and sweet tea. Each 9-inch round cake serves 14 to 20 people for about $60, sans shipping costs. 

If you’re looking for gluten-free cakes, Caroline’s also has a great selection. While she uses gluten-free flour in her selection, including coconut cloud, chocolate mocha, caramel, and Montana Gold (chocolate cake with caramel icing). However, they are baked in the same place as the rest of the inventory, so for those with severe gluten allergies or celiac disease, Caroline’s might not be safe enough. 

Caroline’s Cakes also features the ability to purchase a half cake to mix and match flavors. It also has a selection of cakes for cause, where a portion of the purchase price benefits causes like Red Sneakers for Oakley, the Marvin Hamlisch Music Awards, and the Yellow Ribbon Awards.

And don’t think that Oprah doesn’t know about Caroline’s: She has her own special menu that includes her favorites like coconut raspberry delight, blackberry lime, and red velvet.

Best for Gifting: Bake Me a Wish

Bake Me a Wish

Bake Me a Wish

Why We Chose It 

Bake Me a Wish offers a seamless interface, wide variety, and next-day cake delivery when it comes to choosing a gift for a bridesmaid, groomsman, in-law, or business partner. 

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Easy to navigate website 
  • Posh packaging
  • Very reasonable shipping rates, even overnight

Cons

  • Smaller sizes of cakes
  • No gluten or nut-free options for standard layer cakes

When you want to "wow" someone, Bake Me a Wish offers a fantastic selection of cakes, cookies, brownies, and cheesecake. More than just birthday cakes, Bake Me a Wish also features several varieties of Viennese coffee cakes. 

Although many bakeries ship nationwide, Bake Me a Wish focuses on giftable cakes. Every cake comes in a festive presentation box with a customized greeting card. Iced cakes can have chocolate medallions added imprinted with well-wishes depending on the occasion. And with fast, two-day shipping, overnight shipping, and two-day shipping with Saturday arrival, there are many options to get your cake to its recipient on time, even if you wait until the last minute. 

Bake Me a Wish cakes tend to be a bit smaller: A 7-inch cake feeds six to eight people for about $45. If that doesn’t seem big enough, there's an option of adding a dozen cookies or brownies to any order for roughly an additional $25 to $35 more. Bake Me a Wish has you covered with German Chocolate Cake, NY Blackout Cake, and flourless chocolate cake options for those who crave chocolate.

Final Verdict

There are many fantastic bakeries to choose from now, but We Take The Cake offers the greatest variety of options, including decorated cakes, bundt cakes, and cupcakes. Shipping is included in the price, and delivery is fast and reliable. 

Carousel Cakes will make any birthday brighter with their large selection of sprinkle and confetti cakes for more specialized needs. Those with food sensitivities will feel safe and satisfied with Caroline’s Cakes and their selection of nut-free southern specialties. Carlo’s Bake Shop has an excellent online interface for customizing one of their beautiful designs for the wow factor of a beautifully designed cake. 

If you need a gift fast, Bake Me a Wish offers excellent variety, posh packaging, and fast shipping. 

How to Choose the Best Cake Delivery Service

There are many cake delivery services available now, so choosing can be tricky. Start with timing: When do you need your cake? Some bakeries require advanced notice, so keep that in mind. Next, determine the number of people each cake should serve. Every bakery offers different sizes. Lastly, consider your budget and whether shipping is included in the price of your cake. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Do Cake Delivery Services Cost? 

Cake delivery services range in price but typically start at around $35 for the cake with additional costs for shipping. When looking at prices, consider how many people each cake serves to determine your per-person cost. 

Can You Ship a Cake to Someone Using a Cake Delivery Service?

With many bakeries, you can ship a cake anywhere in the United States. Most bakeries do not require a signature for delivery, though none will deliver to a P.O. box. 

What Types of Cake Can You Order From a Cake Delivery Service? 

Many types of cake are available from a cake delivery service, including holiday cakes, birthday cakes, shower cakes, or just cakes based on traditional or gourmet recipes. 

Methodology 

When researching cake delivery services, we looked for bakeries that offered nationwide shipping in a reasonable amount of time. We searched for bakeries that feature more than one type of cake and have a reputation for quality backed by reviews. Pricing, dietary preferences, and gifting options were also reviewed.

Related Stories