The Great China Pattern Debate

St. Kitts Nag's Head

This black and white design by Kate Spade is the boldest option of the four. "I like how this china incorporates style and texture through various black and white rings," says Cari, "but Jason isn't feeling the contrast in tones."

St. Kitts Nag's Head accent plate, $22, and dinner plate, $25, both Kate Spade for Lenox