Erica and Riva were married in a small civil ceremony in Greenwich, Connecticut, by Erica's grandmother, a retired New York State Supreme Court justice. A few days later, the couple hosted a religious ceremony and reception for 125 guests at a quaint estate on Shelter Island.

Erica and Riva on Shelter Island, NY

One couple holds their wedding at a cozy, tucked-away inn on Shelter Island.

Erica and Riva were married in a small civil ceremony in Greenwich, Connecticut, by Erica's grandmother, a retired New York State Supreme Court justice. A few days later, the couple hosted a religious ceremony and reception for 125 guests at a quaint estate on Shelter Island.

The couple's first dance was to Buddy Holly's "Everyday" by Rogue Wave. "Whenever we hear it we both spontaneously begin to cry," says Riva. "Plus, it's not that long a song, and we're not particularly good slow dancers!"