When it came to the cake, the couple decided to buck tradition and go for a whimsical, peanut-butter-hued wonder. The confection, studded with peanut-butter cups and peanut halves, was one of the highlights of the reception. "Our guests were amazed," Alissa says. "Lots of people took pictures of our cake before we cut it." The cake and all of the catering for the event was provided by Westminster Hotel.