Square Wedding Cake with Star Design

After dancing, the couple cut the cake, which was made by Jim Smeal but designed by Karly to match her invitations. Guests were also able to scoop their own cones with gourmet mint-chip ice cream, which the couple had flown in from Ohio-based Graeter's and displayed on a carved-ice bar. "We wanted every aspect of our wedding to look and feel personalized," says the bride.