How did the reshoot go? I'm curious too! I heard of Kevin Keelan in the Florida area and heard that he is very good.
I really thinnk it is worth paying for a good photographer since these are pictures you are going to be looking at a lifetime. These people sound kinda amateur. Where did you find them? Maybe it was just a bad day but I don't thinnk professionals go on talking about fixing things in photoshop. What a hassle. Let us know how it's going. Get a hold of Kevin keelan in orlando as I'm sure he will know someone too.