Our editors jumped into pools, jogged for miles, and hit the showers to try out wedding-worthy mascaras—so you can feel free to tear up!

It was unanimous—our judges voted this their favorite. They gushed about how it lengthened without creating "those dreaded spidery lashes, like Liza Minnelli's back in the day." This wunderkind provided smooth, weightless coverage, but what sealed the deal was the ease with which it came off. For a waterproof product, that's almost unheard of!

PRICE: $25
MADE FOR: Ladies looking for extra length and serious staying power.