Our editors jumped into pools, jogged for miles, and hit the showers to try out wedding-worthy mascaras—so you can feel free to tear up!

High marks went to this product's slender applicator, which made working on lower lashes easy. ("Even for a klutz like me," admitted a tester.) Everyone went gaga over the fact that the mascara stayed on well and didn't flake or smudge, even when the wearer had done an intense workout or gotten caught in the rain. "I was tired and sweaty after Spinning class, but my lashes still looked fabulous," said one admirer. "Even after I showered!"

PRICE: $20
MADE FOR: Anyone who has trouble with traditional, chunkier wands.