BRIDES New York: The Most Popular Caterers in NYC

Food & Drink, Local, NY, NJ and CT

To help you find the best wedding vendors for your big day, we've teamed up with Wedding Wire to bring you hundreds of florists, venues, cake bakers and other vendors across the country! Not only that, but we've got photos, booking info and real brides' reviews of florists, venues, cake bakers and other vendors in your area. But some of these vendors are rated so highly, that we just had to bring them to your attention. Check out the highest-rated caterers in New York according to Wedding Wire listings below, and click through to see what real brides have to say.

Real Food Catering
Real Food Catering hasn't spent a single dime on advertising, and yet, has the most positive reviews! Their farm-to-table philosophy ensures your reception menu dreams will become a tantalizing reality tailored just for you. And to help make your planning even easier, Real Food Catering also specializes in event planning and the team is ready to manage rentals, party set-up and breakdown, and more. Read real brides' reviews here!

David Josephs Catering
Both graduates of the presitigous Culinary Institute of America, these brothers know how to craft whatever your tastebuds desire. In business for 20 years, you can feel confident in this duo's hands. One bride raved, "They seemed to approach our wedding with the same level of passion and care as if they were handling the wedding of one of their own family. I cannot tell you how special that made us feel or how grateful we are to them for what they did for us." Read real brides' reviews here.

Bartleby & Sage
If you're searching for a company that keeps sustainability and farm-fresh ingredients at the forefront, look no further. Bartleby & Sage works with local farmers, fishermen, and purveyors to bring you the finest naturally grown ingredients, all driven to your event location in their fuel-efficient vehicles. With notable clients including HBO's Sex and The City, Polo/Ralph Lauren, and Food Network, you can rest easy knowing every single guest will feel like a star. Read real brides' reviews here!

See More: Book a Band That Will Keep Your NYC Celebration Going All Night Long!

Betty Brooklyn Catering Company
Much more than just a catering company, Betty Brooklyn Catering Co. will also happily coordinate your bar service, party rentals, professional staffing, day-of planning, and wedding coordination. With previous menus featuring tempting dishes like butternut squash, cauliflower and tomato curry, peking duck, grilled squid skewers, and pistachio cake with cardamom coffee buttercream, Betty Brooklyn will craft the perfect menu just for your special day. Read real brides' reviews here!

Dish Food Events LLC
One look at Dish Food Event's website will make you hungry. With several features in New York Magazine, this boutique Brooklyn-based catering company has made quite a name for itself. A recent bride's enthusiasm spilled over as she exclaimed, "Our guests have consistently commented on the first class service, attention to detail, friendly and helpful staff, the gorgeous presentation, and of course — the food! From the vegans to the meat lovers, everyone enjoyed every bite." Read real brides' reviews here!

Want to see more New York caterers? Check out our New York Catering page to find the catering company of your wildest foodie dreams!

UPDATED Find Local Vendors Button

Give a Subscription to Brides Magazine as a Gift

Get personalized planning advice, exclusive offers and must-read wedding news.

Thank You
for Signing Up!

Check your e-mail inbox for the latest updates from